In partnership with
Good morning.
The title company handling your $500,000 purchase spent their entire marketing budget targeting brokerages while spending nothing to reach you directly. Think they're prioritizing your interests?
Nearly 75% of homes are purchased with a mortgage, and almost every transaction uses title insurance. You're paying for both services, yet lenders and title companies spend the vast majority of their marketing budgets targeting real estate brokerages, not you.
Why? Because brokerages control the referrals. And now, they're taking it a step further.
The Referral Capture System
Lenders and title companies operate in a B2B world where they think their survival depends on staying in the good graces of major real estate brokerages. Challenge the traditional commission-inflated model with transparent listings and direct buyer tools? Watch referrals disappear.
But they're betting on the wrong business model. Consumer-centered approaches that prioritize transparency over padding brokerage revenue are already proving more sustainable.
This creates a perverse loyalty structure: The companies you're paying to serve you are actually serving the brokerages that refer to them. They're trapped in an outdated model that prioritizes maintaining referral relationships over delivering you the most competitive rates or innovative service.
But the real estate industry didn't stop at referral capture. They saw an opportunity to own the entire transaction.
When Referrals Become Revenue Streams
Take Compass Real Estate: they own title companies in California, Colorado, Florida, Washington, Maryland, Virginia, Washington D.C., and Texas. They formed OriginPoint, a joint venture with Guaranteed Rate, to capture mortgage revenue from their clients. Keller Williams has KW Title. Realogy owns Title Resource Group.
These aren't isolated examples. Major real estate brokerages have systematically acquired or partnered with lenders and title companies to ensure they profit from every piece of your transaction.
On a $500,000 purchase, using a brokerage-affiliated mortgage lender could cost you an extra $2,000-$5,000 in fees compared to shopping around. The title insurance markup? Another $500-$1,500. That's $2,500-$6,500 in additional costs flowing back to the same real estate company that already collected an inflated commission on your purchase.
The Better Option They Don't Tell You About
Here's what happens when you break free from the "preferred partner" list: One unaffiliated lender a client discovered on their own saved them nearly $7,000 compared to other options on a $600,000 purchase. The lender wasn't inferior. They simply weren't competing for that brokerage's referral stream.
These options exist. You just never hear about them because they've been effectively shut out by brokerages protecting their affiliated business empires.
Here's What to Do
When your agent provides lender or title company recommendations, first ask: "Are any of these companies owned by or affiliated with your brokerage?"
If the answer is yes, request at least two unaffiliated options. Regardless of affiliation status, always get at least two quotes—three if you have time to compare properly.
Most consumers never do this. They trust the "preferred partner" list represents their best options. But those lists are built to maximize brokerage revenue, not your savings.
Want guidance from an advisor who prioritizes your interests over referral relationships? Visit PropertyPage.com to schedule a free consultation with a trusted real estate advisor. I'll show you how to navigate these affiliated business relationships and ensure you're getting service providers chosen for your benefit, not brokerage profits.
I've watched major brokerages build empires around controlling every profit center in your transaction. Housing is a necessity in life. You deserve to know who profits from every dollar you spend.
Next week
The comparable sales your agent uses to price your home include inflated commission costs—meaning you're overpaying before you even list. I'll show you how to use this hidden pricing advantage to list for less, sell faster, and still net more than your competition.
Also worth noting
Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway and Zillow say mortgage rates can’t fall enough for Americans to afford a home (Fortune)
Magnificent 7 earnings hold the key to quelling bubble fears (Opening Bell Daily)
Fannie Mae and MBA agree: Most of the mortgage rate relief is already behind us (ResiClub)
About me
I'm Mathew Speer, creator of PropertyPage.io, the first consumer centered, fully transparent real estate listing platform. After 20 years investing and 14 years as an agent, I authored The Consumer's Guide to Buying and Selling Real Estate and write this newsletter to expose industry dysfunction and arm consumers with insider knowledge.
Home insurance rates up by 76% in some states
Over the last 6 years, home insurance rates have increased by up to 76% in some states. Between inflation, costlier repairs, and extreme weather, premiums are climbing fast – but that doesn’t mean you have to overpay. Many homeowners are saving hundreds a year by switching providers. Check out Money’s home insurance tool to compare companies and see if you can save.